Pulse newmasthead 10th anniv 2252x376px

About More Voices

Every month More Voices invites readers to contribute short nonfiction prose pieces of 40 to 400 words on a healthcare theme.

submittomorevoices

Subscribe/Energize


new subscription

Join the 11,000+ who receive Pulse weekly



energize subscription 
Energize your subscription
with a contribution and
keep
Pulse vibrant



Liz Witherell

I donated blood today. I'm one of those people who doesn't shudder at the thought of needles piercing my skin, or get queasy as I watch the blood drain from my vein into the collection bag. It's no big deal. I eat the cookies and drink the juice afterwards, and I kind of enjoy talking with the elderly volunteers.

I think I'm lucky. I know so many people who are sickened by the sight of blood, afraid of needles and terrified at the thought of pain.

Several years ago, a nurse-practitioner friend convinced me to volunteer a few hours a week at a free dental clinic. I took health histories and blood pressures. By the time people came to us, their teeth were generally beyond saving. Their mouths were infected, their gums were inflamed, and they often had other conditions, such as diabetes and heart disease. But still they'd put off coming to the clinic as long as possible, because they were afraid it would hurt.

They weren't wrong--but I always thought the pain was a small price to pay. If they could only tolerate the procedures, they would leave with a set of dentures that would allow them to eat again, to smile without feeling self-conscious, to be free of infection.

But fear can make you myopic. It's hard to see a distant outcome, no matter how sunny, when you're blinded by fear.

When my friend Sally's husband, Ed, got sick, she made every effort to make him well. She made him smoothies to build him up against the cancer that was ravaging his body. She stayed by his side; tried to remain in his sight. Even during his last days, as he drifted into and out of consciousness, he was aware of her presence and agitated by her absence. Sally did everything in her power to care for him.

But some things were not in her power--including pretty much anything medical. She had a strong fear of medical procedures and required assistance with tasks I considered mundane. For example, she couldn't bring herself to place the transdermal pain patches on Ed's back.

"It's just like a Band-Aid," I would tell her. But she just couldn't do it.

Three months after Ed died, I was having lunch with Sally and her daughter. Sally told me that her leg was giving her trouble, and that her daughter was taking her to the urgent-care center that afternoon. She commented on the size of the hamburgers we were served--the smaller, quarter-pound versions with no sides. "I don't know how people can eat such huge portions."

At the urgent-care center, they found a deep vein thrombosis in Sally's leg. Since they could find no obvious risk factors in her health history, they sent Sally for a CT scan. She was full of clots. Soon after, she was diagnosed with stage IV pancreatic cancer.

"When will you start chemo?" I asked Sally.

"Oh, I'm not going to do that," she said matter-of-factly. "There's no cure, you know."

I had trouble processing this decision. How could she make it so quickly? The treatment would be difficult, but it could extend her life at least a few months. She had a wonderful family and many friends who were ready and willing to take care of her for as long as it took. She could at least start the treatment and see how the tumor responded before making a final decision. What about the possibility, no matter how remote, that a cure or promising clinical trial might be found during those months?

Sally's response to such arguments made it clear that they were not open to consideration:

"I'm not afraid to die."

And nothing that happened in the two remaining months of her life convinced me that she felt otherwise. She stopped all medical treatment except for comfort measures and entered hospice care in her home. She lay in her custom bed and looked out the windows of her sun-filled bedroom. She took pain medications as needed. She laughed and enjoyed the company of others. She had a wonderful portrait taken of her family in funny Easter bonnets. It was such a joy to be with her; her daughter never had any problem getting volunteers to help with her care. We all happily took shifts.

And then, one morning, she quietly passed away.

During the time she was ill, she did learn to overcome some of her fear of medical procedures. For example, she had to have daily insulin injections to control her blood sugar. Her daughter was terrified of giving these, so to shield her from this abhorrent task, Sally found the strength to do it herself. I was amazed at how far she had come.

But to myself I always thought, If I had received Sally's diagnosis, I would have fought it with every medical tool available--chemo, radiation, clinical trials of any kind. I wouldn't have spent my last months in a sunny room on a soft bed; I would have been hooked up to tubes, puking my guts out. I wouldn't have been afraid of anything. Bring it on. Anything, that is, except death.

After her death, I realized that I was the one blinded by fear. Sally could clearly see the outcome she wanted: as much time as possible to feel well and enjoy her family; a calm and dignified death. And, because of her bravery, those are the things she got.

Sally was an inspiration to me. But even now, I don't think I could accept a terminal diagnosis as calmly as she. My faith in medicine would probably compel me to try a more aggressive form of treatment if it were offered. I believe that I would need the time, and perhaps the suffering, to come to terms with my fate. When I ran out of options, I would enter hospice, as Sally did, because I believe that hospice is a wonderful and humane healthcare option for terminal patients.

But my most fervent hope is that if faced with a terminal diagnosis I would know when to stop--and that, like Sally, I would be able to find acceptance and serenity before death.


About the author:

Liz Witherell became a registered nurse after retiring from twenty-five years in the computer industry. Her second career was inspired both by an interest in science and by family members who are medical professionals. Most recently, she has been working in the quality department of the St. John Providence Health System, in the Detroit area. "Writing has always been a healing and creative outlet for me. I publish short stories, essays and poems on my blog, lizwitherell.com."

Story editor:

Diane Guernsey

Comments   

# Bill McLaughlin 2015-12-06 17:21
This is a wonderful, beautifully written reminder of a basic fact of medical work: almost everything important we know about life we learn from our patients. To meet and care for one person truly reconciled to death increases our own repertoire of possible reactions, and as this story shows creates a life altering tension between what we assume they should do (what we might do) and what they choose to do.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
# Warren Holleman 2015-12-05 19:56
Very thoughtful. Thanks for sharing this with us. I will send a link to my palliative care friends. (Not because they need it, but because they will appreciate it! And your words will validate the good work they do.)
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
# Ron Banner MD 2015-12-05 06:40
Congratulations , Liz, on so personal and beautiful a story.

With modern biomedicine's focus on EMR, guidelines, etc., it can miss the emotional part of medical caring.

And, there is probably no more important emotion behind the scenes than fear - and fear of dying.

One of the challenges health care professionals face is to determine when to switch from aggressive, curative care to aggressive, palliative care.

If one can address this challenge and the emotions involved, then we can get (in the words of a medical ethicist) "the least worst death."

Death is a part of life. When we can look back at our life and feel good about it, when we have competent and caring health carers, the fear of dying is less.

Your story and your feelings crystallize this process for us.

Thank you.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
# Lee Kagan 2015-12-04 20:16
Terrific writing. Loved the voice.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
# Henry Schneiderman 2015-12-04 19:51
Another terrific story, full of insight and wisdom. As a palliative care person, I am so pleased that the two most recent have been in this domain. Am hoping the surgeons and ENTs and radiologists who subscribe to Pulse won't feel shortchanged! Am going to share this one with my palliative team.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
# Pris Campbell 2015-12-04 19:19
A good article on a difficult decision. I've always felt that with an incurable cancer I wouldn't want to spend my last bit of time on chemo vomiting, but would I have the courage to say no? I don't know.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote